Running a nonprofit means balancing your mission with meeting important legal and financial obligations. A nonprofit accounting compliance checklist helps ensure your organization stays on track. By using this checklist, you can protect your tax-exempt status, stay trustworthy, and remain financially healthy.
Let’s explore why compliance matters and break down the key steps to keep your nonprofit in good standing.
Why Accounting Compliance Matters for Nonprofits
Nonprofits enjoy benefits such as tax exemption and access to public funding. However, they must meet high standards of transparency and accountability in return.
Proper accounting compliance isn’t just “red tape”; it directly impacts your credibility. Staying compliant helps:
- Keep Your 501(c)(3) Status: Submitting required IRS forms, such as Form 990, on time helps you avoid losing your tax-exempt status. If you fail to file for 3 years in a row, the IRS will automatically revoke your exemption.
- Maintain Public Trust: Donors and grantmakers expect transparency. Compliance (accurate financial reports, public 990 filings, etc.) builds trust by showing you steward funds responsibly.
- Prevent Penalties and Legal Problems: Not filing or breaking rules could lead to daily fines, audits, or even lawsuits. For example, if you don’t register in a state before raising money, or if you give incorrect financial reports, you might face penalties from the state or fines from the IRS.
- Meet Donor and Grant Needs: Many foundations and sponsors want proof that you follow their rules. This may include recent reports or audited financial records before they give you money. By maintaining compliance, you will have the necessary data and documents to show your financial responsibility and qualify for additional funding opportunities.
- Focus on Your Goals (Not Problems): Keeping your records tidy and your filings up to date helps you spend less time fixing compliance issues. Proactive compliance helps you feel secure. This way, you can concentrate on your goals instead of rushing to fix preventable issues.
In short, accounting compliance is the backbone of a healthy nonprofit. It preserves your legal status, reputation, and financial stability, all of which help you serve your community effectively.
State Requirements vs. IRS Requirements for Nonprofit Compliance
Nonprofits must follow federal IRS rules and state laws. Keeping track of both is important to meet all compliance requirements.
Compliance happens on two levels: federal requirements (IRS) and state requirements. It’s important to understand the differences:
Federal (IRS) Requirements:
- Obtaining and keeping 501(c)(3) tax-exempt status is handled by the IRS.
- Nonprofits must file an annual information return (Form 990 series) to report finances and activities. The type of 990 depends on your revenue (more on that below).
- The IRS also sets rules against private benefit, excessive lobbying, and political campaigning.
- Employment taxes (like payroll withholding and Medicare/Social Security) must be paid to the IRS for any employer.
- The IRS looks at unrelated business income, too. If you have taxable income from activities not related to your main purpose, you need to fill out Form 990-T.
State Requirements:
- Every state has its own rules for nonprofits. These can include yearly forms, charity registration, state tax forms, and other requirements.
- Most states ask nonprofits to file a yearly or every two-year report with the Secretary of State. This report needs to confirm your address, registered agent, and leaders. If you don’t file it, you might lose your “good standing” status.
- In more than 39 states, you must register if you ask for donations from people living there. You also need to renew this registration every year.
- States may also require separate applications to be exempt from state sales tax or property tax.
- If you run a business or raise money in different states, you need to track the registrations and deadlines for each state.
Issues Nonprofits Face With Compliance
- Missed Deadlines & Filings: There are many forms to fill out, like 990s and state renewals. It’s easy to miss a deadline by mistake.
- Complex Regulations: Nonprofit tax and finance rules can be complex.
- Multi-State Compliance Confusion: If your organization fundraises in multiple states (even just via an online donate button accessible nationwide), the compliance workload multiplies.
- Limited Internal Controls: Some nonprofits (especially smaller ones) face challenges maintaining proper financial controls due to limited staff.
- Mismanagement of finances: Poor management can result in audits, penalties, or revocation of tax-exempt status, with devastating consequences.
- Board Engagement and Oversight: Sometimes, nonprofit boards do not pay enough attention to managing finances.
- Resource Constraints: Unlike for-profit companies, nonprofits may not budget much for administrative compliance costs.
The Nonprofit Compliance Checklist
This checklist is organized by key compliance areas that nonprofits should manage constantly. Use it as a roadmap to fortify your organization’s governance, financial practices, nonprofit audit prep, and legal standing.
Governance & Organization:
- Maintain up-to-date articles of incorporation, bylaws, and key policies (conflict of interest, whistleblower, document retention).
- Hold regular board meetings; record minutes and review finances at each meeting.
- Renew corporate registration/annual report with your state to stay in good standing.
- Keep a list of current board members and officers; report any changes as required.
IRS Filings & Tax-Exempt Status:
- File Form 990 (990-N/990-EZ/990) every year by the deadline (or file for extension). Mark calendar ~4.5 months after fiscal year-end.
- Monitor unrelated business income – file Form 990-T if gross UBI ≥ $1,000.
- Retain your IRS determination letter and IRS correspondence in organizational records for grant applications and donor inquiries.
- If you have employees, file quarterly Form 941 and annual W-2s; if applicable, Form 940 for unemployment.
State & Local Compliance:
- Register for charitable solicitation in each state where you fundraise; renew these registrations annually before expiration.
- File required annual/biennial reports with the state corporations office to maintain incorporation status.
- Apply for any state tax exemptions (sales tax, property tax) and renew as required.
- Hold required state licenses or permits (e.g., business license, raffle permit) for your operations/events.
- Submit state payroll filings and unemployment insurance reports if you have employees, and secure workers’ compliance insurance.
Financial Management & Controls:
- Use fund accounting to keep track of restricted and unrestricted funds separately. Make sure to use donor-restricted funds only for their intended purpose.
- Perform monthly bank reconciliations for all accounts; have a second person review them.
- Prepare internal financial statements (balance sheet, income statement with budget vs actual) at least quarterly for board review.
- Allocate revenues and expenses to grants/programs/cost centers.
- Implement internal controls: segregate financial duties, require dual approvals for large expenses, and secure blank checks and cash.
- Approve an annual budget and compare actual results to the budget regularly; adjust spending as needed.
- If receiving grants, track grant budgets and spending closely; keep documentation for all grant-funded expenses.
Audit & Accountability:
- Determine if you need an independent audit or a CPA review. Check your state’s laws, or if you meet the federal $750,000 audit requirement.
- If you qualify for an audit, get your documents ready in advance. This includes financial statements, the general ledger, bank statements, records of donors and grants, and past audit reports.
- Engage an audit committee or finance committee to liaise with auditors and review the audit report.
- After an audit, implement any recommendations or corrective actions suggested in the management letter.
Even if it’s not necessary, think about doing a voluntary audit or review every few years if you can. This can help assure stakeholders and make processes better.
Fundraising Compliance:
- Send donation acknowledgment letters for all gifts (and absolutely for ≥$250) with required IRS language. Aim to send by January 31 or within weeks of the gift.
- Issue any required quid pro quo disclosures (for donations where the donor received something in return valued >$75).
- Manage restricted gifts properly – get donor intent in writing and track usage; report back to donors as appropriate.
- Ensure any raffles/lotteries have permits and follow state gaming rules. Register any professional fundraisers or commercial co-venture arrangements as required.
- Be truthful in all fundraising materials; avoid any misleading statements about the use of funds.
Human Resources & Payroll:
- To classify workers correctly, use IRS and DOL guidelines. Here are key points to consider:
- Employee: A person who works for you, and you control what they do and how they do it. You provide tools, and they follow your instructions. They may get benefits like health insurance and paid time off.
- Contractor: An independent worker who has more control over their work. They decide how to do their job and often use their own tools. They don’t usually get benefits from you.
- When unsure, it’s safer to classify someone as an employee.
- If you hire remote employees, ensure you are aware of state-specific compliance laws.
- Pay at least minimum wage and overtime if required (for non-exempt staff). Maintain timekeeping records.
- Withhold and deposit payroll taxes timely (federal and state); file all returns (941s, state withholding, etc.).
- Make sure to give new hires important information. For example, provide any required state pamphlets. Follow FMLA rules and local paid leave laws if they apply.
- Keep personnel files confidential and maintain records like I-9 forms, W-4s, etc., as required by law.
- Regularly review that your insurance (workers’ comp, liability) is adequate and active.
Recordkeeping & Policies:
- Implement a records retention policy, financial records 7 years, payroll records per law, permanent retention for key corporate docs.
- Protect sensitive data: Use passwords and multi-factor authentication for digital files. Lock cabinets for paper files. Limit access to donor and financial information.
- Ensure you have a cloud-based backup infrastructure.
- Shred or securely delete records that are no longer needed (according to policy) to protect confidential information.
- Annually review IT security, update antivirus, educate staff on phishing, and back up data offsite.
- Maintain an inventory of assets (equipment, laptops, etc.) and conduct asset checks.
Ongoing Compliance Management:
- Choose one staff member or a committee to oversee compliance tasks. Also, make sure to train other staff members so they can help too.
- Use a compliance calendar with automatic reminders for all key dates and tasks (tax filings, license renewals, etc.).
- Do an internal compliance check every year. Make sure all forms are filled out, rules are followed, and find any problems to fix.
- Stay updated on nonprofit rules. Sign up for a nonprofit newsletter or get updates from your state group. This way, you can learn about changes like new filing fees or law updates.
- Engage outside experts as needed: CPAs for accounting questions, attorneys for governance or employment questions. It’s better to ask and do it right than to guess and err.
What To Do
With the detailed checklist above in mind, here is a quick-hit list of things you should do to keep your nonprofit compliant:
- Do create a compliance roadmap/checklist
- Do invest in strong back office support.
- Do train and inform your team about new regulations and best practices
- Do review and refine policies regularly
- Do invest in a robust tech-stack.
- Do seek expert help when needed
What Not To Do
Avoid these common pitfalls that can derail your nonprofit’s compliance and even its reputation:
- Don’t miss required filings
- Don’t commingle funds
- Don’t ignore donor restrictions or grant terms
- Don’t wait until year-end for financial oversight or audit preparation.
- Don’t misclassify or under-document your staff and volunteers
Staying vigilant against these “don’ts” will help your nonprofit avoid many common compliance failures.
FAQs About Nonprofit Accounting Compliance
What happens if a nonprofit fails to file Form 990?
If a nonprofit fails to file Form 990 three consecutive times, it triggers automatic IRS revocation of tax-exempt status; reinstatement is costly, and donors can’t claim deductions.
How often should our board review financial statements?
Financial statements should be reviewed at least quarterly. Monthly reviews are best practice. Regular oversight ensures transparency and early issue detection.
Do all nonprofits need an audit?
Not all nonprofits need a compliance audit, only if required by state law, federal funding thresholds ($750K+), funders, or bylaws. Small nonprofits can opt for a CPA review or compilation. Nonprofits with over $250,000 in annual revenues require a review in the State of Maryland.
How do I know which states to register in for charitable solicitation?
Register in any state where you actively solicit donations (mail, email, events, or targeted online campaigns). Most states—around 40—require registration.
What’s the risk of misclassifying a worker?
Misclassification can lead to back wages, unpaid payroll taxes, penalties, and legal fines. Always verify status and correct errors promptly.
Strengthen Your Compliance With These Nonprofit Accounting Best Practices
Accounting compliance builds the foundation of a stable, trustworthy nonprofit. Staying compliant proves credibility to donors and funders, safeguards your tax-exempt status, and helps you plan programs with confidence.
If managing it all feels overwhelming, Goldin Group CPAs can help you maintain compliance, streamline your accounting, and free your team to focus on advancing your mission.

